For my lack of references and forethought but I'm going to blog this topic anyway.*
I've been following Nicole, aka Paragraphein and her experience being censored by the administration of the Bethany Christian Services forums. I've been listening to Nicole for a long time. Like many others, I'd have to say that my ideas of adoption were all positive (that is, I thought adoption was a purely positive thing - a good solution to bad situations) before I started paying attention to what she had to say. Now, my perspective is drastically different. As you know, if you've been reading, I don't really know what I believe about adoption these days. It tears me up.
A long time ago Nicole mentioned something about countries like Holland and Australia have minuscule numbers of domestic voluntary adoptions compared to the U.S. The Captain did some digging around in some Dutch language resources (and here is where my lack of references comes into play) and he found that in Holland, there are approximately 50 in-country adoptions a year. 50 The Dutch adopt internationally, but the kind of domestic voluntary placements we have here are quite uncommon. They do keep track of the numbers, and that's what they are...50.
Why? What's the difference?
Off the top of my head (where this all comes from anyway) I think of a couple of things.
1. State funded (read: crazy taxes on higher wage earners and everyone else) health care.
2. Free birth control pills to women under 21 (the age cap is a new regulation, it used to be for all women, period).
3. The normalized use of birth control for all women (single and married professing Christians not excepted).
4. A silence surrounding abortion - for better or for worse, it's a silent issue.
5. State subsidization of housing for 20-40% of citizens with less than average income.
6. The absence of private schools and homeschooling being against the law leading to greater homogeny in the education system which is one of the best in the world.
Okay, so what am I saying here? (That question is for myself) First of all, women and girls are less likely to get pregnant unintentionally in the first place. They have greater access to birth control and there is less stigmatization in using it. If a woman becomes pregnant and decides to terminate, that option seems to be more easily available to her. If a woman becomes pregnant and decides to carry the baby, issues like health care, access to education and housing for herself and the baby are less of a factor in the decision making process. They may still be factors but I think that they are less.
If we had some of these same systems in America would we see plummeting voluntary placement rates? How many would there be? 50? I wonder.
*And to any of my Dutch family reading, or to the Captain, please feel free to chime in with why you think Dutch women don't voluntarily place their children for adoption as often as American women do, or more accurate statistics if I have misrepresented these.